Looking for influencers isn't difficult. Finding the right influencers is.

With more than 200 million creators worldwide, brands have never had more choice. But more choice doesn't necessarily mean better campaigns.

One of the biggest reasons influencer marketing campaigns underperform isn't poor creative or low budgets. It's choosing creators based on follower count instead of genuine brand fit.

At Pepper, we've identified thousands of creators for brands across travel, retail, FMCG, beauty, finance and lifestyle. One thing we've learnt is that successful creator identification is part data, part strategy and part human judgement.

Here's how we approach finding influencers that actually deliver results.

What is creator identification?

Creator identification is the process of finding influencers who are the right fit for your campaign, audience and objectives.

It's much more than searching for someone with a large following.

The best creator identification considers:

• Audience demographics
• Audience interests
• Content quality
• Brand alignment
• Previous partnerships
• Engagement quality
• Authenticity
• Cultural relevance
• Platform expertise

In other words, the question isn't:

"Who has the biggest audience?"

It's:

"Who can influence the audience we actually want to reach?"

1. Start with the audience, not the influencer

One of the biggest mistakes brands make is beginning their search with creators.

Instead, begin with your audience.

Ask yourself:

• What communities are they part of?
• What conversations are they having?
• Which creators do they already trust?
• What type of content do they engage with?

Once you understand that, finding relevant influencers becomes much easier.

2. Search by topics, not just people

The best influencer searches don't begin with names.

They begin with interests.

Modern creator discovery tools now allow marketers to search by topics before identifying relevant creators, making it easier to uncover people genuinely shaping conversations within a niche.

Instead of searching for:

• Fitness influencers

Try searching around:

• Marathon training
• Running communities
• Home workouts
• Women's strength training

You'll often discover creators your competitors haven't found yet.

3. Use hashtags strategically

Hashtags remain one of the easiest ways to find influencers organically.

But they're often misunderstood.

Keywords reveal what creators talk about.

Hashtags reveal the communities they actively contribute to.

For example:

Searching #RunningCommunity will produce a very different creator list to simply searching "running".

The former identifies people consistently creating content within that community.

That's usually a much stronger indicator of expertise.

4. Don't forget to exclude creators

Finding influencers isn't just about who to include.

It's about who shouldn't make your shortlist.

Modern discovery platforms now make it easier to exclude creators associated with competitors, previous campaigns or specific hashtags, helping marketers build cleaner, more relevant creator lists.

That saves hours of manual review.

5. Build flexible searches

Not every campaign requirement is equally important.

Rather than making every filter mandatory, advanced search tools now allow marketers to distinguish between essential and preferred criteria.

For example:

Must

• UK audience
• 20,000-150,000 followers

Should

• Sustainability
• Lifestyle
• Parenting

Must not

• Competitor partnerships

The result is a larger pool of relevant creators without compromising quality.

6. Build your own creator database

One of the smartest investments any brand can make is creating its own creator database.

Every campaign generates valuable insight.

Which creators delivered?

Who was easy to work with?

Who created exceptional content?

Who drove measurable results?

Rather than starting from scratch every campaign, build a library of trusted creators organised by industry, audience, platform and performance.

Many discovery platforms now support curated creator lists as part of the search process, making future sourcing even more efficient.

7. Never rely on AI alone

AI has transformed influencer discovery.

It can analyse millions of data points in seconds.

It can recommend creators you've never heard of.

It can speed up research dramatically.

But it still can't tell you whether a creator truly feels right for your brand.

That's where people make the difference.

How Pepper identifies influencers

At Pepper, we believe the best creator identification combines technology with human expertise.

We use leading creator discovery platforms to analyse audiences, identify trends and build an initial pool of potential creators.

Alongside that, we've developed our own database of trusted influencers from years of delivering successful campaigns. Every creator has been assessed not just on reach, but on creative quality, professionalism, campaign performance and brand suitability.

Then comes the part AI can't replicate.

Our influencer specialists manually search social platforms every day. We spend time in the communities our clients want to reach, uncovering emerging creators, niche voices and rising talent before they appear in automated recommendations.

Every creator is reviewed by a member of our team.

We assess:

• Creative quality
• Brand fit
• Audience relevance
• Storytelling ability
• Tone of voice
• Previous partnerships
• Content consistency
• Authentic engagement

Because no algorithm can fully answer one simple question:

Would this creator genuinely make someone stop scrolling?

That's still a human decision.

Finding the right influencers starts with asking better questions

Influencer marketing has evolved.

Finding creators is no longer the challenge.

Finding the right creators is.

The brands seeing the greatest success today aren't simply working with the biggest influencers. They're partnering with creators who genuinely connect with their audience and can tell authentic stories that drive action.

At Pepper, we combine industry-leading discovery technology, our own trusted creator database and hands-on human sourcing to identify creators that deliver more than impressions. They deliver influence.

‍