Everyone Wants Brand Communities. So Why Is Nobody Funding Them?

Published on
November 19, 2026
Share this post

Community is one of those words that gets thrown around a lot in social media marketing.

Every brand wants one. Every social strategy talks about building one. And every marketing presentation seems to include something about creating meaningful connections with audiences.

But when it comes to actually investing in community management, the enthusiasm starts to look a little different.

In our latest 2027 Social Media Trends Playbook, we asked marketers what they're planning to prioritise next year, and consumers what they'd like to see more of from brands.

The results revealed something interesting.

42.9% of marketers plan to increase community engagement in 2027, while 30.7% of consumers want to see more of it from brands.

So far, so good. Both sides agree that community matters.

But when we asked marketers where they'd prioritise spending if their budgets increased by 20%, just 4.8% selected community management as their first choice.

Which raises a pretty obvious question.

If everyone agrees community is important, why are so few marketers prepared to put money behind it?

Community Is Becoming a Bigger Priority for Brands and Consumers

For years, social media marketing has been heavily focused on publishing content and reaching audiences.

Brands invest in creative production, build content calendars, launch campaigns and use paid media to get their messages in front of the right people.

And while those things are still important, there's a growing recognition that social media shouldn't be a one-way conversation.

People don't necessarily want to follow brands simply to receive a constant stream of promotional messages. They want useful information, relevant interactions and opportunities to engage with businesses that understand their interests.

Our research suggests marketers recognise this.

With 42.9% planning to increase community engagement, there's clearly an ambition to move beyond content distribution and develop stronger relationships with audiences.

And consumers are interested too, with 30.7% saying they'd like brands to prioritise more community engagement.

It's one of the areas where the two groups are broadly aligned.

But building a community takes more than deciding to post more interactive content.

It requires consistency, attention, resources and, perhaps most importantly, a willingness to actually listen.

The Community Management Budget Gap

Here's where the disconnect becomes difficult to ignore.

As part of our research, we asked marketers how they would allocate an additional 20% of social media budget in 2027.

Paid social was the clear winner, selected by 36% of marketers, followed by creator and influencer marketing at 21.4% and content production at 19%.

Community management attracted just 4.8%.

Now, there's nothing wrong with investing in paid media, creators or content production. These are all important parts of an effective social strategy, and different businesses will naturally have different commercial priorities.

But it's interesting that community engagement is something marketers want to do more of, without necessarily prioritising the resources required to deliver it.

Because communities don't manage themselves.

Someone needs to respond to questions, participate in conversations, moderate discussions, recognise recurring contributors and understand what audiences are actually saying.

And if those responsibilities are consistently treated as an afterthought, it's difficult to see how brands can build the meaningful relationships they're aiming for.

Community Management Is More Than Replying to Comments

Part of the problem might be how community management is perceived.

For some businesses, it's still treated as a relatively straightforward task: publish the content, monitor the comments, respond when necessary and escalate anything that looks like a customer service issue.

But effective community management can be much more valuable than that.

It's an opportunity to understand audiences in real time.

The questions people ask, the frustrations they share, the recommendations they make and the conversations they start can reveal information that doesn't always appear in campaign reporting.

For example, a beauty brand might notice recurring questions about how to use a particular product. A retailer could identify common concerns about delivery or sizing. A travel brand might discover that audiences are looking for practical advice about destinations rather than more aspirational imagery.

Those insights can help shape future content, product messaging, customer experience and even wider marketing strategy.

But only if someone is paying attention.

The comment section isn't just somewhere to manage reactions to your content. It's somewhere to understand the people you're trying to reach.

And that understanding becomes increasingly valuable as brands compete for attention in crowded social feeds.

Why More Content Doesn't Automatically Build Community

One of the biggest misconceptions about community building is that increasing content output will naturally lead to stronger engagement.

Post more often, ask more questions, run more polls and encourage people to comment.

And while interactive content can help start conversations, it doesn't automatically create a community.

There's a difference between generating engagement and building relationships.

A post might receive hundreds of comments because it's entertaining, controversial or particularly relevant to a trending topic. But that doesn't necessarily mean those people feel connected to the brand or want to return.

Community is built through repeated interactions and shared value.

It's what happens when people recognise a brand's personality, feel comfortable participating in conversations and believe their contributions are being noticed.

That could mean responding thoughtfully to questions, featuring community contributions, developing content around audience feedback or creating opportunities for people with shared interests to connect.

And importantly, it means being consistent even when there isn't a major campaign running.

Brands can't expect to build loyal communities if they only engage with audiences when there's something to promote.

The Commercial Value of Community Is Bigger Than Engagement

One reason community management may struggle to attract budget is that its commercial contribution can be harder to demonstrate than paid advertising performance.

With paid social, marketers can often report on impressions, clicks, leads, conversions and return on ad spend.

Community management doesn't always fit into such a straightforward measurement framework.

But that doesn't mean it lacks commercial value.

An effective community strategy can support customer retention, improve brand sentiment, generate audience insights and help businesses identify issues before they become bigger problems.

It can also contribute to the wider customer journey.

Someone asking a question about a product might be closer to purchasing than someone who simply liked a promotional post.

A helpful response could remove uncertainty, while an unanswered question might mean the customer goes elsewhere.

Similarly, when people see brands responding thoughtfully and consistently to their audiences, it can help build confidence in the business.

That doesn't mean every comment needs to be attributed to a sale.

It means recognising that community engagement can contribute to outcomes beyond social platform metrics.

Brands should be thinking about response quality, recurring participation, sentiment, customer questions resolved and the insights being fed back into the business.

Where possible, those measures can be connected to customer experience, retention and commercial performance.

Could Smaller Communities Be More Valuable Than Bigger Audiences?

Another interesting development is the growing importance of smaller, interest-led communities.

For a long time, social media success has been closely associated with scale.

More followers, more impressions, more reach.

But a large audience isn't necessarily the same thing as an engaged community.

A brand with hundreds of thousands of followers might struggle to generate meaningful conversations, while a smaller community built around a shared interest could have far stronger participation.

This is something our Pepper team and Hot 30 contributors have been thinking about in their predictions for 2027.

As audiences become more selective about where they spend their time, there's an opportunity for brands to develop deeper connections through niche communities, private groups and interest-led experiences.

That might mean creating spaces for customers to share advice, developing recurring community content or working with creators who already have strong relationships with particular audiences.

For some brands, it could also mean bringing those communities together offline through events, workshops or experiences.

The important thing is that the community exists for a reason beyond receiving brand messages.

People need to get something from participating.

And if brands can provide that value consistently, the relationship has the potential to become much more meaningful than a follow or a like.

How Can Brands Make Community Management a Bigger Priority?

If community engagement is genuinely going to become a bigger part of social strategy in 2027, brands need to think about how it's resourced and measured.

That doesn't necessarily mean every business needs a dedicated community team or a completely new budget.

But it does mean making community management an intentional part of the strategy rather than something squeezed in around other responsibilities.

Start by defining what community means for your brand. Is the priority customer support, product education, brand advocacy, shared interests or deeper relationships with existing customers? Different objectives require different approaches.

Give someone clear ownership. Community management needs time, attention and accountability. Make sure responsibilities, response expectations and escalation processes are understood.

Use conversations to inform content. Regularly review the questions, concerns and interests emerging from your audience, and feed those insights into the content planning process.

Create reasons for people to participate. Think beyond promotional posts and develop opportunities for audiences to contribute, share experiences and feel involved.

Measure relationships, not just reactions. Look at the quality of conversations, recurring engagement, response times, sentiment and the impact community activity has on wider business objectives.

The aim isn't simply to generate more comments.

It's to build stronger relationships with the people who already care about your brand, while giving new audiences a reason to become part of the conversation.

Pepper's Take: You Can't Build a Community on Leftover Budget

At Pepper, we talk a lot about the importance of brands creating meaningful connections with audiences.

But our 2027 research highlights a pretty important contradiction.

Marketers want more community engagement. Consumers want more community engagement. Yet when there's an opportunity to invest additional budget, community management is one of the least popular priorities.

And that's worth questioning.

Because community isn't something that magically appears once you've published enough content or gained enough followers.

It's built through conversations, consistency and showing audiences that there's someone on the other side of the account who actually cares about what they have to say.

We're not suggesting brands should suddenly divert their paid media budgets into replying to Instagram comments.

But we do think community management deserves to be recognised as a strategic part of social media marketing, rather than a task that happens once everything else is finished.

Especially when brands are increasingly talking about loyalty, advocacy, authenticity and long-term relationships.

Those things don't come from reach alone.

What excites us most is the opportunity to connect community management with the rest of a brand's social strategy.

The conversations happening in comments and messages can inspire better content. The questions audiences ask can shape creator briefs. Community insights can inform paid creative, and the relationships brands build can create opportunities for advocacy and real-world experiences.

But only when community is given the attention it deserves.

If community is genuinely a priority for 2027, it needs to show up in more than the strategy deck. It needs to show up in the budget, the team and the way success is measured.

Because brands don't build communities by talking at people.

They build them by giving people a reason to keep talking back.

Want to see where marketers and consumers agree, where their priorities differ and what it means for social media in 2027? Explore Pepper's 2027 Social Media Trends Playbook, featuring original research, industry predictions and practical recommendations for brands.

Thank you! We appreciate your message!
Oops! Please try again later.
Partner
with
Pepper

Ready to elevate your marketing strategy?
Let’s add some spice to your next campaign 🌶️